Lookalikes to rule out
Deadly Galerina
deadlyGalerina has rusty-brown spores, a ring zone, and no latex when the gills are cut.
Red-hot milk cap
toxicLactarius rufus releases white, acrid latex rather than watery whey.
Other small brown milk caps
cautionSimilar milk caps lack the maple smell; dry a sample to confirm.
Identification
Candy caps are small, with dry orange-brown caps that often have a slight central bump. Break a gill and a clear, watery latex seeps out rather than white milk. The stem is hollow and brittle. When dried, the mushroom smells strongly of maple syrup or fenugreek.
Uses and ecology
Candy caps are mycorrhizal and saprobic along the Pacific coast and are used almost like a spice, dried and added to desserts. Because several small brown mushrooms grow in the same debris, experienced foragers check each individual rather than a whole patch.
Memorable fact
The maple scent comes from sotolon, the same compound that gives fenugreek and maple syrup their smell.
