Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
Wine Cap
deadlyWine cap is much larger, with a wine-red to tan cap, a thick ring with a cogwheel pattern and a purple-black spore print.
Psilocybe species
deadlyPeople seeking psychoactive mushrooms have eaten conecaps; Psilocybe spores are purple-brown.
Fairy Ring Mushroom
deadlyFairy ring mushrooms have white spores and tough stems.
Deadly Galerina
deadlyGalerina also contains amatoxins and has rusty-brown spores.
Identification
The cap is small, rarely over 2.5 cm, conical to bell-shaped, and orange-brown. Gills are rusty brown. The thin, fragile stem carries a small movable ring. It fruits in lawns, mulch, and wood chips.
Why it matters
This tiny mushroom contains the same amatoxins as the death cap. It is a particular risk to young children and dogs who eat mushrooms in lawns and landscaping.
Memorable fact
It is one of the smallest mushrooms known to carry enough amatoxin to endanger a person.
