Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
The Sickener
toxicThe sickener is scarlet with pure white gills, a white spore print and no brown staining.
Other red Russula
cautionMany red Russulas are toxic and look alike. Do not taste them to tell them apart; rely on spore print color, staining and a qualified local expert.
Charcoal Burner
harmlessCharcoal burner has flexible gills and mixed violet-green colors.
Identification
The cap is variable, from wine red and purple to olive brown. Gills are cream to yellowish and brittle. The flesh and stem bruise yellow, then brown, and the stem is often flushed pink. Older specimens smell distinctly of shrimp or crab.
Uses and ecology
Shrimp russulas are mycorrhizal with conifers and are well regarded among edible Russulas. The fishy smell fades with cooking.
Memorable fact
The seafood smell gets stronger as the mushroom ages.
