Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
Beechwood sickener
toxicRussula nobilis grows with beech and is also acrid.
Shrimp Russula
toxicShrimp russula has a fishy smell, yellowish gills, and bruises brown.
Other red Russula
toxicRed Russulas are hard to tell apart and several are toxic. Do not taste them to separate them; leave red Russulas unless a qualified local expert confirms the species.
Charcoal Burner
toxicCharcoal burner has a mixed violet, gray and green cap and white gills that bend without breaking.
Identification
The cap is bright scarlet, and its skin peels almost to the center, revealing pink flesh. Gills and stem are pure white. The flesh is brittle and crumbly. Field guides describe its taste as burning hot, but tasting is not a safe way to identify any wild mushroom: rely on the white spore print, white gills, habitat and a qualified local expert.
Why it matters
The sickener is a classic example of a gastrointestinal irritant mushroom. It forms partnerships with conifers in damp woods.
Memorable fact
Its scientific name emetica refers to vomiting, the effect it causes.
