Lookalikes to rule out
Western Matsutake
deadlyMatsutake has a spicy odor, a sheathing ring, and no scaly, rooting base.
Matsutake
deadlyThe Asian and European matsutake shares the same field test: odor and stem base.
Catathelasma
cautionCatathelasma is larger and has a double ring and decurrent gills.
Identification
The cap and stem are white and covered with cottony to shaggy veil fragments. The stem tapers into a rooting base with bands of scales. It has a bleach-like or chlorine smell. It lacks the spicy, cinnamon odor of matsutake.
Why it matters
Smith's amanita contains an amino acid that damages the kidneys. Early gastrointestinal symptoms can seem mild, but kidney failure can follow days later. Most reported cases involved people seeking matsutake.
Memorable fact
The kidney toxin in this mushroom is chemically unrelated to the amatoxins in death caps.
