Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
False Death Cap
deadlyFalse death cap, including its white form, has a rimmed, rounded bulb instead of a loose sac and smells of raw potato. Treat any white Amanita as deadly.
Horse Mushroom
deadlyAgaricus have gills that turn pink to brown and no volva.
Puffballs
deadlyCut every white button vertically; Amanita eggs show gills and a cap outline.
St George's Mushroom
deadlySt George's mushroom fruits in spring and has no ring or volva.
Identification
Everything is white. The cap is conical to bell-shaped, often lopsided. The stem is shaggy with woolly scales and carries a fragile ring that may disappear. The base sits in a large, loose, sac-like volva, often buried. Gills are white and free.
Why it matters
Like the death cap, this species contains amatoxins that destroy liver cells. Symptoms begin 6 to 24 hours after eating, followed by a deceptive improvement and then liver and kidney failure.
Memorable fact
Its old English name, destroying angel, was given for its combination of purity of color and extreme toxicity.
