Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
St George's Mushroom
toxicSt George's mushroom drops white spores and fruits in spring.
Clouded agaric
toxicClitocybe nebularis is gray with white spores and decurrent gills.
The miller
toxicThe miller is smaller with decurrent gills.
Aborted Entoloma
toxicAborted entoloma is a gray gilled mushroom on wood or buried wood, often beside white aborted lumps. Its gilled form shares pink spores with toxic Entoloma, so do not separate them without an expert.
Deer Mushroom
toxicDeer mushroom has free gills that turn pink and grows on dead wood; livid pinkgill has attached gills and grows from soil.
Identification
The cap is large, pale gray to buff, with a silky surface. Young gills are yellowish, turning salmon pink as spores mature. The smell is mealy. The spore print is pink, the decisive check.
Why it matters
This species is responsible for a large share of mushroom poisonings in parts of Europe. It causes severe gastrointestinal illness that can last days.
Memorable fact
Its pleasant, mealy smell resembles several edibles, which adds to its danger.
