Lookalikes to rule out
Each label is the worst outcome if the two are mixed up, in either direction: harmless, caution, toxic or deadly.
Meadow Mushroom
toxicMeadow mushroom does not stain yellow and smells pleasant.
Horse Mushroom
toxicHorse mushroom yellows slowly and smells of aniseed.
Destroying Angel
deadlyDestroying angels have white gills and a volva.
Wine Cap
toxicWine cap has a wine-red to tan cap, attached gray-purple gills, a thick ring with a cogwheel pattern and a purple-black spore print, and does not stain yellow at the base.
Identification
The cap is white, often squarish in outline when young. Scratch the cap edge or cut the base of the stem and it turns bright chrome yellow within seconds. The smell is of ink, phenol, or hospital disinfectant, strongest when cooked. Gills turn pink, then brown.
Why it matters
Yellow stainer causes vomiting and diarrhea. Some people tolerate it, which gives it an inconsistent reputation, but it is responsible for many Agaricus poisonings.
Memorable fact
The yellow fades to brown within minutes, so check a fresh cut.
